Airports: Buy, Hold or Sell?

WHIT 202007 Airports main image

Airports: Buy, Hold or Sell? 

Whitehelm Capital

With lockdowns across the globe slowly lifting and signs that global economies are emerging from hibernation, is now the time to invest in airports? Valuations certainly are cheap relative to history with global airport stocks down over 40% over the last 4 months. The question becomes how long it will take before air traffic goes back to normal and which airports have a strong enough balance sheet and sufficient liquidity to survive. Consumer behaviour also has a part to play. When will the public feel safe enough to fly? Retail investors have piled into the sector in recent months with a buy the dip mentality, but many institutional investors are long-term investors in the sector. We discuss the appeal of this sector with Whitehelm’s Portfolio Manager Ursula Tonkin who has held her nerve and airport stocks during this pandemic.

1) Ursula, what percentage of the Whitehelm listed core infrastructure fund is held in airports?

Whitehelm hold three airport stocks: Zurich Airport, Paris Airport and Aena, an operator of Spanish airports with a total weight of 7% of the portfolio. These are preferred over other options such as Sydney or Auckland airports, both of whom are significantly more levered with less cash flow cover of interest payments on debt. Overall, the portfolio was conservatively positioned at the start of the year with two thirds of the portfolio in fully regulated utilities and only 25% in transportation infrastructure including airports, railways and tollroads.

WHIT 202007 Airports Chart 1

2) You hold these airports in your portfolio despite the travel industry grinding to a halt over the last few months. Can you explain why you chose to hold on to these stocks?

Through March and April our airports team spent a lot of time analysing the liquidity of the airport stocks and modelled the cash flows and debt covenants under a conservative recovery scenario. As a result, we were comfortable with the financial viability of three airport stocks and felt that the share price declines more than reflected the outlook. We haven’t added to the exposure however, as the prospects for a recovery in traffic is more uncertain than previous negative shocks such as the SARS epidemic in 2003. This is because (1) travel restrictions in some form may continue for some time even if the spread of the virus seems contained; (2) the deteriorating global economic outlook would likely slow the recovery in traffic and consumer spending, even if travel restrictions are eased; and (3) the crisis is also weakening the credit profile of airlines, which have been drastically cutting capacity. Our base case is that passenger numbers are severely depressed for 6 months, with a gradual recovery over the following 18 months, reaching 2019 levels in mid-2022, and zero growth for the rest of 2022*.

3) Have you made any changes to your holdings in the sector?

Yes, the result of our analysis was that we were comfortable with some exposure to the airports sector, including our holdings in Zurich Airport and AENA holdings, but we sold out of Frankfurt Airport and purchased Paris Airport. The share prices of both Frankfurt and Paris airports had been similarly impacted, around -45% from mid-February to the March lows, but Paris Airport has a much more secure liquidity position, so for the same valuation, we swapped to the higher quality asset.

Frankfurt Airport balance sheet is covenant light, which is good, but the company already had an above average debt load and the main concern is the large capex program, which they have only limited ability to delay without incurring large penalties. With the existing leverage, should the company not be able to access credit markets, this would require a very dilutive equity raising. In contrast, Paris Airport has lower overall leverage and a significant cash position.

WHIT 202007 Airports Chart 2

4) What about the ongoing costs airports are incurring while passenger traffic is subdued?

The airports do have operating costs that can’t be avoided, so they will be burning cash through this period. For example, Aena had 2019 operating costs of c.€210 million per month, on revenues of ~€370 million per month (a 43% operating margin) but has started a cost-savings plan based on renegotiating service contracts (security, cleaning, maintenance, etc), and the halting of new non-essential contracts, all leading to a target operating expenditure reduction of circa €43 million per month.

5) What is your view on the sector going forward?

We believe Aena, ADP Group (Paris Airport) and Zurich Airport have responded appropriately to this crisis, aggressively cutting costs, deferring capital expenditure and suspending 2020 dividends to preserve liquidity. Further, we believe these three operators have sufficient committed liquidity to continue to operate, while maintaining adequate headroom to financial covenants, under the Base Case which assumes a sharp reduction in passengers over the period of April to August, with a modest recovery for the second half of 2020. While the extent of this outbreak and ensuing impact on economic activity is difficult to estimate, under a protracted outbreak and slower economic recovery, they should continue to be able to access the debt capital markets. Aena and ADP in particular benefit from their categorisation as Government-related issuers. We believe that the sector is a hold and dividends will resume as passenger traffic improves over time.

Ursula Tonkin head of listed strategies at Whitehelm Capital

View the article as a PDF here.


This is a marketing communication and is not, and should not, be considered as independent investment research. It is issued in the UK and the EU by Fidante Partners Europe Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) and is issued in Australia by Fidante Partners Limited which holds an Australian Financial Services Licence (234668). 

UK and EU: This marketing communication and the services and products described herein are for persons who are Eligible Counter-parties or Professional Clients (for the purposes of the FCA rules) only and it is not available to Retail Clients. It is being distributed (a) in the United Kingdom to, and is directed only at, persons who are (i) investment professionals as defined in Article 19 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (the “Promotion Order”) or (ii) are persons to whom this marketing communication may otherwise lawfully be issued or passed on or (b) outside the United Kingdom to, and is directed only at, persons to whom this marketing communication may be lawfully issued or issued without compliance with any filing, registration, approval or other requirement in the relevant jurisdiction, and in each such case without the inclusion of any further warnings or statements as required by the Promotion Order, or other applicable law or regulation, which are not included in this marketing communication (all such persons together being referred to as “relevant persons”). Neither this marketing communication nor any of its contents may be received by, acted on or relied on by persons who are not relevant persons. 
This marketing communication is for information purposes only and does not constitute, and should not be viewed as, an offer, invitation or solicitation in respect of securities or any other related financial instruments and contains information designed only to provide a broad overview for discussion purposes and should not form the basis of, or be relied upon for the purpose of, any investment decision. As such, all information and research material provided herein is subject to change and this marketing communication does not purport to provide a complete description of the funds, securities or other investments or markets referred to or the performance thereof. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice and do not constitute advice and should not be relied upon. 

This marketing communication is based upon information which Fidante Partners considers reliable, but such information has not been independently verified and no representation is made that it is, or will continue to be accurate or complete and nor should it be relied upon as such. Neither Fidante Partners, any member of the Challenger Limited group nor any of their directors, officers, employees or agents accepts responsibility for, or duty of care in respect of, such information or its accuracy or completeness, either now or in the future. Recipients of this marketing communication must conduct their own investigation as to the accuracy and completeness of the information contained in it. Recipients of this marketing communication should note that: all investments are subject to risk; the value of shares may go down as well as up; you may not get back the full amount that you have invested; past performance is not a guarantee of, and cannot be relied on as a guide to, future performance; fluctuations in exchange rates could have adverse effects on the value or price of, or income derived from, certain investments; certain numbers have been supplied by underlying funds on an interim basis from the regularly scheduled reporting and therefore such numbers may not be accurate or complete; such numbers may be estimates and may be unaudited or subject to little verification or other due diligence and may not comply with generally accepted accounting practices or other valuation principles; investments denominated in foreign currencies result in the risk of loss from currency movements as well as movements in the value, price or income derived from the investments themselves. Before entering into any transaction, an investor should take steps to ensure that the risks are fully and completely understood and whether the investment suits the objectives and circumstances, including the possible risks and benefits of entering into such a transaction. An investor should also consider seeking independent advice on the nature and risks associated therein. 

This communication has been disclosed to Whitehelm Capital Pty Limited (Investment Manager) and, where appropriate, included in this communication. Fidante Partners or a member of the Challenger Limited group have a minority equity interest (greater than 5% of issued share capital) and fee entitlement in the Investment Manager or an equity interest (which may be greater than 5% of issued share capital) in the UCITS Fund or the Australian Fund. Fidante Partners is remunerated by fees for services provided and a share of profits. There is no direct link between the remuneration of individuals at Fidante Partners and the recommendations or transactions tied to services provided by Fidante Partners. Fidante Partners does not produce buy, sell or hold recommendations with respect to specific securities. Unless otherwise stated, this communication will not be regularly updated. Fidante Partners has policies, internal organisational and administration arrangements and information barriers to prevent or manage the conflicts which may arise in the production of non-independent research, including preventing dealing ahead. 

The information in this document is current as at the date of publication and is provided by Whitehlem Capital ACN 008 636 717 AFSL 244434. 

It is intended to be general information only and not financial product advice and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.