How Diversification, Infrastructure can Offset 'Black Swan' Risks

WHIT 20200520 Diversification Black Swan 2

How Diversification, Infrastructure can Offset 'Black Swan' risks 

Whitehelm Capital

The turmoil we have seen in markets over the past few weeks has served as a timely reminder of the importance of diversification in portfolios, both across asset classes and within them.

Infrastructure as a sub-sector within equities has outperformed the broader market given that demand for utilities is more inelastic than other sectors.

For example, households need to keep the lights on, and communication networks need to function regardless of how well the economy is performing. Utilities such as water and electricity supply grids represent over 50 per cent of the infrastructure index. Performance across other parts of the infrastructure sector such as transport will be more variable depending on demand.

Listed infrastructure has been a popular asset class for investors over the past decade, largely due to the consistent, stable cash flows that infrastructure assets produce relative to other sectors. However, investing in the listed infrastructure sector comes with its own sector specific risks.

Depending on how infrastructure is defined, companies can have varying exposure to economic cycles and energy prices. Infrastructure companies also typically have high levels of debt, and with large physical assets, can be subject to stock-specific tail risk, or "black swan" event risk. Holding a well-diversified portfolio, and investing only in strictly defined "core" infrastructure companies can mitigate some of these risks.

One recent example of black swan risks includes the wildfires in California in late 2018 that eventually forced the regional electric utility company PG&E into Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.

Another example is the bridge collapse in Genoa, Italy, in 2018. This catastrophe caused a major correction in the shares of Italian infrastructure company Atlantia Spa. The individual stock price moves are displayed in the exhibit below.

Black swans hit Atlantia and PG&E

WHIT 202004 Diversification Black Swan chart  

These event risks show that simply restricting your investments to core infrastructure does not protect the portfolio to a severe event or “tail” risk,  often stemming from natural catastrophes like wildfires, earthquakes or windstorms. And no matter how much you analyse a business, if an earthquake hits, the share price will suffer dramatic declines without any warning.

The global COVID-19 pandemic is the latest example of an event risk. Although the pandemic is affecting most company’s share prices due to the economic impact; airports, railroads and other transport assets have been among those hit the hardest as many countries have gone into lockdown.

The impact on share prices in this sector has been severe as the length of the shutdown and effect on earnings is hard to gauge until the crisis resolves. Ultimately those with strong balance sheets, good management and low debt are likely to emerge stronger than their competitors in the aftermath.

Because such “black swans” are unpredictable, one way to mitigate this is to give an equal weight to each stock in a core infrastructure portfolio. This results in a much more diversified portfolio, particularly when compared with the market’s capitalisation weighting. After all, why should a specific catastrophe like a wildfire or a pandemic be more likely to hit a large company than a small company?

An equal-weighted approach to investing means that even if a black swan occurs, there will be no outsize impact on the portfolio from exposure to one stock. In a 40-stock infrastructure portfolio with equal weights, the weight of each stock is about 2.3 per cent to 2.5 per cent.

This means that in August 2018 when the bridge in Genoa collapsed, Atlantia had a weight of 2.4 per cent in the equal-weighted portfolio compared with 4.7% in the S&P Global Infrastructure Index. The subsequent 30 per cent decline in the share price of Atlantia would have detracted only 0.7 per cent from the equal-weighted portfolio and led to fewer losses than the S&P Global Infrastructure Index.

Similarly, the falls in share markets that we have seen in recent weeks highlight the importance of spreading risks across different industries. An equal-weighted approach can help prevent excessive losses in a portfolio of core infrastructure stocks and act as an additional risk management tool in the face of unpredictable risks.

Minimising tail risk

The benefits of an equal-weighted allocation to stocks tend to come to the fore when investors need them the most. In an equal-weighted portfolio large companies do not have an outsized weight and consequently do not drag down the portfolio in case of an unexpected crisis or natural catastrophe.

The diversification benefits of equally weighted stocks minimise the risks of any tail risk event which occurs to any one infrastructure company.  This simple balanced approach to allocating capital has served investors well in the past for a portfolio of private infrastructure assets.

Ursula Tonkin head of listed strategies at Whitehelm Capital


To view the PDF click here


This is a marketing communication and is not, and should not, be considered as independent investment research. It is issued in the UK and the EU by Fidante Partners Europe Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) and is issued in Australia by Fidante Partners Limited which holds an Australian Financial Services Licence (234668).

This marketing communication is for information purposes only and does not constitute, and should not be viewed as, an offer, invitation or solicitation in respect of securities or any other related financial instruments and contains information designed only to provide a broad overview for discussion purposes and should not form the basis of, or be relied upon for the purpose of, any investment decision. As such, all information and research material provided herein is subject to change and this marketing communication does not purport to provide a complete description of the funds, securities or other investments or markets referred to or the performance thereof. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice and do not constitute advice and should not be relied upon.

This communication contains written material that is generic in nature and not related to a specific financial instrument. It is not personalised to reflect the circumstances of an individual client and therefore does not amount to a personal recommendation to any person. It does not contain any substantive analysis and does not and is not intended to recommend or suggest any investment strategy or opinion as to the future value or price of financial instruments of any kind. This communication is also made openly available at the same time to any investment firms wishing to receive it or to the general public on the Fidante Partners website Recipients of this communication based in the EEA who are subject to regulation under MiFID should note that while they must make their own determination Fidante Partners is of the view that this communication constitutes a “minor non-monetary benefit”. This communication will not be regularly updated.

This marketing communication is based upon information which Fidante Partners considers reliable, but such information has not been independently verified and no representation is made that it is, or will continue to be accurate or complete and nor should it be relied upon as such. Neither Fidante Partners, any member of the Challenger Limited group nor any of their directors, officers, employees or agents accepts responsibility for, or duty of care in respect of, such information or its accuracy or completeness, either now or in the future. Recipients of this marketing communication must conduct their own investigation as to the accuracy and completeness of the information contained in it. Recipients of this marketing communication should note that: all investments are subject to risk; the value of shares may go down as well as up; you may not get back the full amount that you have invested; past performance is not a guarantee of, and cannot be relied on as a guide to, future performance; fluctuations in exchange rates could have adverse effects on the value or price of, or income derived from, certain investments; certain numbers have been supplied by underlying funds on an interim basis from the regularly scheduled reporting and therefore such numbers may not be accurate or complete; such numbers may be estimates and may be unaudited or subject to little verification or other due diligence and may not comply with generally accepted accounting practices or other valuation principles; investments denominated in foreign currencies result in the risk of loss from currency movements as well as movements in the value, price or income derived from the investments themselves. Before entering into any transaction, an investor should take steps to ensure that the risks are fully and completely understood and whether the investment suits the objectives and circumstances, including the possible risks and benefits of entering into such a transaction. An investor should also consider seeking independent advice on the nature and risks associated therein.

This communication has been disclosed to Whitehlem Capital Pty Limited ACN 008 636 717 AFSL 244434 (Investment Manager) and, where appropriate, included in this communication. Fidante Partners or a member of the Challenger Limited group have a minority equity interest (greater than 5% of issued share capital) and fee entitlement in the Investment Manager or an equity interest (which may be greater than 5% of issued share capital) in the UCITS Fund or the Australian Fund. Fidante Partners is remunerated by fees for services provided and a share of profits. There is no direct link between the remuneration of individuals at Fidante Partners and the recommendations or transactions tied to services provided by Fidante Partners. Fidante Partners does not produce buy, sell or hold recommendations with respect to specific securities. Unless otherwise stated, this communication will not be regularly updated. Fidante Partners has policies, internal organisational and administration arrangements and information barriers to prevent or manage the conflicts which may arise in the production of non-independent research, including preventing dealing ahead. Whitehelm Capital has reviewed this communication and has approved it.

It is intended to be general information only and not financial product advice and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.